Showing posts with label Alan Alda. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alan Alda. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Alan Alda and the popularization of science


"How to woo an audience, with help from Alan Alda"

In late October, 30 scientists spent two days in a communication workshop, learning that successful communication is both simpler and riskier than they realized.

by

Lori Ann White

November 1st, 2012

Symmetry

About 30 scientists from SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory and Stanford University threw caution—and, sometimes, their dignity—to the wind last week during a two-day science communication workshop sponsored by the Kavli Foundation. The workshop, conducted by faculty of the Center for Communicating Science at Stony Brook University, sought to provide better communication skills to scientists, who can then use their new skills to convey the essence of their research to lay audiences. Award-winning actor and writer and long-time science advocate Alan Alda gave the workshop's keynote address.

During the hands-on portion of the workshop, participants stepped out of their comfort zones, practicing interviewing skills and delivering their messages to different types of audiences—messages they also practiced distilling to the most relatable, most understandable essence.

But, as the old saying goes, you can't find the derivatives of covariant tensors before you learn to handle vector fields. Before anyone, scientist or not, has a hope of getting an idea across, the lines of communication with the audience must be open, and making that connection requires effort.

Which explains why these 30 researchers at all different stages in their careers gathered in conference rooms and introduced themselves with funny gestures, played the mirror-mirror game made infamous by mimes, and tossed imaginary balls of energy to each other. "TeV or GeV?" quipped one of the participants.

The instructor, Valerie Lantz-Gefroh, laughed at the joke along with the rest, after a bit of explanation from the scientists in the room. Then she gently corrected them. The balls floated on the energy of affection, wobbled with misunderstanding, drilled forward in anger, she said. They represented human energies used to forge human connections.

The workshop's focus on human connections addresses a concern laid out by Alda during his keynote address to the group. A founding member of the Center for Communicating Science's advisory board, Alda said he fears the United States is on a perpetual blind date with science, with all the awkwardness, misunderstandings and occasional outright distaste that implies. And since science is the metaphorical suitor on the doorstep, roses and wine bottle in hand, the scientists trying to explain their research have the onus placed on them to make that good first impression and, if that doesn't work, to keep trying.

But the Center and Alda are there to help. Alda's own passion for science—and scientists—is evident. He hosted the PBS show "Scientific American Frontiers" for more than a decade, and often participates in the workshops. "When I work with them in a workshop like this I see so much exuberance," he said. "It's a lovely thing to see."

Alda himself might have pursued a scientific career, except, as he explained, "I came of age in the time of the Two Cultures," referring to British scientist and writer C.P. Snow's influential essay positing a gulf between the two intellectual cultures of the humanities and the sciences. "I knew I wanted to be an actor and a writer, so I thought science was closed to me." A case of bad communication in a poorly taught trigonometry class sealed the deal.

But though his joy in scientific discovery might be vicarious, it remains profound. "They start with the tiniest bit of data," he said, speaking in this case of cosmologists and astrophysicists in the group, "and because they're rigorous and exacting and logical they can discover some of the most fundamental properties of the universe. It's breathtaking."

Alda himself is an example of the blind date blossoming into a deep love affair. Sounds like the perfect qualification for matchmaker.

As part of the workshop, Alda also gave a public lecture, "Helping the public get beyond a blind date with science." Watch Alda's talk, presented by the Center for Communicating Science with underwriting by the Kavli Foundation, below.


Alan Alda: Helping the Public Get Beyond a Blind Date with Science


Friday, October 3, 2008

"Flash of Genius"--movie review

Alan Alda, Lauren Graham, Greg Kinnear, and director Marc Abraham

Okay, Christopher Kelly of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram was not impressed, but then, that is his opinion. Critics have panned good movies before.

"MOVIE REVIEW: 'Flash of Genius'"

by

Christopher Kelly

October 3rd, 2008

Fort Worth Star-Telegram

An actor so effortlessly charming and endearing that you assume, deep down, he must be harboring some kind of filthy secret, Greg Kinnear has been perfectly cast in "Flash of Genius," Marc Abraham's fact-based drama about an all-American family man driven to madness when corporate America tries to take credit for one of his groundbreaking inventions.

Too bad the rest of the movie seems to have been crafted on an assembly line that specializes in inspirational tales of ordinary Davids triumphing over merciless Goliaths. Kinnear gives it his all here, lending dark shadings to a familiar cinematic figure (see Francis Ford Coppola's "Tucker," a movie to which this new film owes a vast debt). But Abraham so belabors his central theme, and he's so determined to put a lump in the viewer's throat, that he ends up losing sight of what makes the story interesting in the first place.

Based on a New Yorker magazine article by John Seabrook, "Flash of Genius" introduces us to university engineering professor and part-time inventor Bob Kearns (Kinnear), who, in 1962, while driving home from church with his family, experiences the titular lightning bolt: Why, he wonders, can't automobile windshield wipers operate like the human eyeball, and be designed to wipe intermittently? It might not sound like much, but at the time all of the major auto companies were working on this elusive invention. (Previously, all wipers wiped at the same medium-rate speed, regardless of whether it was a downpour outside or a drizzle.) When Kearns figured out the secret to making this new wiper work, and partnered with a local auto dealer (Dermot Mulroney) to bring the design to Ford, he naturally assumed he'd soon be a millionaire.

Enter the corporate slimeballs, who from the moment they appear on the screen we know are going to try to steal the design. The first hour of "Flash of Genius" is a familiar slog, designed to make the audience sympathize with this earnest soul who just wants to get credit where credit is due. Except no one seems to have told Abraham that Kearns didn't write "Hamlet" or cure cancer. He created a utilitarian object, one that it's hard to feel any emotion about, and one whose creation is awfully hard to make dramatic.

The bigger problem is that there's a curious gap between what the movie proclaims it's about, and what Kearns' life story (and Kinnear's performance) would seem to reveal. In the second half of "Flash of Genius," Kearns goes on an almost messianic crusade to get credit for his design and to bring the Ford Motor Company to court. Forsaking the wishes of his wife (Lauren Graham) and the practical advice of his lawyer (a sterling Alan Alda, whose two scenes here are the very best of the movie), he turns into a bristling, extremely unlikable figure. His arrogant refusal to accept that, in the United States, justice is usually meted out via out-of-court settlements ultimately costs him his family and sends him into the loony bin.

With each successive scene, Kinnear's performance turns darker and knottier. The actor shows us, just beneath that all-American veneer, lurks a man whose ego tramples everything in sight. (He plays a similar, if slightly more lighthearted version of the same character in another current movie, the wonderful romantic comedy "Ghost Town.")

The screenplay by Philip Railsback, however, takes Kearns' side throughout all of this. It accepts a given that his decades-long effort in bringing the case to court was a good thing. But was it? I sat through "Flash of Genius" wishing Kearns would take the million dollar settlements being dangled in front of him and stop his bellyaching. Less than a story of righteousness triumphing over greed, "Flash of Genius" mostly struck me as a two-hour-long advertisement for our country's desperate need for tort reform. (Seabrook's article makes the case that Kearns' efforts altered the way we view copyright law in this country, a topic that the film - perhaps out of fear of sending the audience into a deep coma - avoids altogether.)

A better director would have been able to address the moral problems raised by Kearns' actions - or perhaps used the man's story (the way Coppola did in "Tucker") as a metaphor for how artistic creation can sometimes destroy its creator. But Abraham, a longtime producer ("Children of Men," "Bring it On") and studio executive, resists all forms of subtlety, visual and textual. With its square framing and squeaky clean images, "Flash of Genius" looks like a Lifetime movie; and with its periodic pauses to allow the characters to deliver speeches that articulate the theme of the movie, it's about as complicated as one, also.

By the final 20 minutes, an interminable courtroom showdown in which Kearns represents himself (while the movie tries to teach us sticky-sweet lessons about the importance of family holding together through tough times), a potentially terrific lead performance has been sabotaged and the likable supporting cast has drifted into the woodwork. "Flash of Genius" might have been better titled "Not a Shred of Inspiration."

But then, Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times wrote...

"Flash of Genius"

by

Roger Ebert

October 2nd, 2008

Chicago Sun-Times

Why do corporations tend to be greedy? I suspect it's because their executives are paid millions and millions to maximize profits, minimize salaries and slash benefits that cut into the bottom line. Sometimes this can be taken to comic-opera extremes, as when the (now) convicted thief David Radler was stealing millions from the Sun-Times and actually turned off the escalators to save on electricity. I guess that helps explain why the Ford Motor Co., followed by Chrysler, stole the secret of the intermittent windshield wiper from a little guy named Robert Kearns.

Why bother? Why not just pay the guy royalties? Simple: Because Ford thought it could get away with it. He was only a college professor. They had teams of high-priced lawyers with infinite patience. They risked having the legal fees cost them more than the patent rights, but what the hell. You can't go around encouraging these pipsqueaks.

I know that I sound just like a liberal, but at this point in history I am sick and tired of giant corporations running roughshod over decent people -- cutting their wages, polluting their work environment, denying them health care, forcing them to work unpaid overtime, busting their unions and other crimes we have never heard George Bush denouncing while he was cutting corporate taxes. I am sure lower taxes help corporations to function more profitably. Why is that considered progress, when many workers live in borderline poverty and executives have pissing contests over who has the biggest stock options?

But enough. I have "Flash of Genius" to review. Yes, I am agitated. I am writing during days of economic meltdown, after Wall Street raped Main Street while the Bush ideology held it down. Believe me, I could go on like this all day. But consider the case of Robert Kearns, played here touchingly by Greg Kinnear. He was a professor of engineering, a decent, unremarkable family man, and had a eureka! moment: Why did windshield wipers only go on and off? Why couldn't they reflect existing conditions, as the human eyelid does?

Working in his basement, Kearns put together the first intermittent wiper from off-the-shelf components and tested it in a fish tank. He patented it in 1967. He demonstrated it to Ford, but wouldn't tell them how it worked until he had a deal. After Ford ripped it off and reneged on the deal, he sued in 1982. Thirteen years later, he won $30 million in a settlement where the automakers didn't have to admit deliberate theft.

"Flash of Genius" tells this story in faithful and often moving detail. If it has a handicap, it's that Kearns was not a colorful character, more of a very stubborn man with tunnel vision. He alienates his family, angers his business partner (Dermot Mulroney) and sorely tries the patience of his lawyer (Alan Alda), who he is not afraid to accuse of incompetence. Was his victory worth it? The movie asks us to decide. For Kearns, as depicted in this movie, it was. If he had not been obsessively obstinate, Ford would have been counting its stolen dollars.

The movie covers events taking place from 1953 to 1982. The wiper was hard to perfect. There are some gaps along the way, and we don't get to know his wife (Lauren Graham) and his family very well, nor perhaps does he. He calls his kids his "board of directors," but they mostly resign, only to return loyally in the end. Alda gives the film's strongest performance. Kinnear, often a player of light comedy, does a convincing job of making this quiet, resolute man into a giant slayer.

Todd McCarthy of Variety notices an odd fact: Right to the end, Kearns always drove Fords. He remained loyal. I remember those days. You were a Ford, a Dodge, a Cadillac or a Studebaker family, and that's what you remained. It was nice when sensible wipers were added to the package. Thanks, professor.