Mr. Whipple--comet man

NASA:

On April 20, 2007, the comet had just dipped inside the orbit of Mercury, perilously close to the sun, when a solar eruption struck and literally tore the comet's tail off. This surely has happened to comets before, but for the first time in history a spacecraft was watching. NASA's STEREO-A probe recorded a fantastic movie of the collision.

"We were speechless when we saw this," says Angelos Vourlidas of the Naval Research Lab in Washington, D.C. "I kept playing the movie over and over."

Vourlidas is part of a team of NRC researchers who built the Heliospheric Imager telescope onboard STEREO-A that recorded the event. He's also the lead author of a paper reporting the collision in the Oct. 10 issue of the Astrophysical Journal Letters.

The eruption that hit Encke was a CME or "coronal mass ejection." Sky watchers on Earth are familiar with CMEs because of the auroras they create when they occasionally hit our planet. CMEs are fast-moving and massive, packing billions of tons of solar gas and magnetism into billowing clouds traveling a million-plus miles per hour.

Actually, it is a little surprising that a CME succeeded in ripping off a comet's tail. For all their mass and power, CMEs are spread over a large volume of space. The impact of a gossamer CME exerts little more than a few nanoPascals of mechanical pressure—softer than a baby's breath.

The ripping action must have been something else.

"We believe the explanation is 'magnetic reconnection,'" says Vourlidas. Magnetic fields around the comet bumped into oppositely directed magnetic fields in the CME. Suddenly, these fields linked together--they "reconnected"--releasing a burst of energy that tore off the comet's tail. A similar process takes place in Earth's magnetosphere during geomagnetic storms powering, among other things, the aurora borealis.

"In a sense, the comet experienced a geomagnetic storm," says Vourlidas. "It is the first time we've ever witnessed such an event on another cosmic body."

"Although STEREO is primarily designed to study CMEs and their impact on Earth, we hope this CME strike on Encke will provide insights to scientists studying comets as well," adds Mike Kaiser, STEREO project Scientist at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center.

Among astronomers, Encke is one of the most famous and important comets. It was only the second comet named, after Halley itself, and it is the shortest-period comet known. Encke loops around the sun once every 3.3 years compared to, say, once every 75 years for the more typical Halley.

Encke's short period combined with its trajectory inside the orbit of Mercury means it may have been blasted by CMEs more often than any other comet routinely observed by astronomers. Could this have some effect on the comet's nature and evolution? "We don't yet know."

Vourlidas' team is only beginning to study all the data gathered by STEREO. The spacecraft carries a suite of five different telescopes (collectively known as SECCHI) each optimized for a different kind of observation ranging from wide-angle views of CMEs at visible wavelengths to pinpoint maps of sunspots through high-resolution ultraviolet filters. The Heliospheric Imager movie represents just a fraction of the total dataset. In the months ahead, "we're going to be looking at the CME-comet interaction in much greater detail to understand the processes at work," says Vourlidas.

NASA Comet Encke Movie

Such is life and death in the universe and this marks a segue to the man who loved comets...Fred Whipple.

Fred Lawrence Whipple
1906 to 2004

I am sure that most don't even know who Fred Whipple was. I remember him for two very significant things: One was a new hypothesis regarding comets and the other a unique technological feature of fooling radar--significant for military purposes. It was far back in the early 1950's that Fred Whipple suggested that comets were a mixture of ice and rocks and hence the "dirty snowball" hypothesis. He further suggested that the ice core of comets were heated by solar methods and the ejecta was responsible for orbital changes. And thus in 1986, spacecraft flybys of Halley's Comet confirmed the hypothesis. The technological achievment was a novel idea that consisted of dispersing aluminum flakes to confuse radar. And, he also developed the "Whipple Shield" that protect spacecraft. A current space project is called "Stardust" which encountered Comet Wild-2 in January this year. In honor of his contributions the craft will carried a microchip with the following letter from Fred Whipple.

"Center For Astrophysics

Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA

November 25, 1997

To all Space Buffs:

Comets have long been an unexplored wasteland. Today we know that they are black and cold, consisting of ices and dust that coalesced from an interstellar cloud as it collapsed to form the solar system.

Their physical structure is poorly known. Some astronomers guess that comets have low densities, perhaps less than half that of water ice. This material would be crushable in one's hands. Even the ratio of ices to dust remains a subject of uncertainty. Probably the physical structure varies over small distances such as a few meters.

May Stardust tame comets to become terra cognita, of known structure and isotopic composition!!"

Fred L. Whipple


Read more...

"Astronomy Section - Comets"

"At age 92 astronomer Fred Whipple is joining NASA space team to explore three comets in 2002"

"STARDUST REVEALS SURPRISING ANATOMY OF A COMET"