Henri Moissan...no, he didn't make diamonds

"Moissan's furnace"

by

Andrea Sella

June 3rd, 2013

Chemistry World

In the public mind, the chemist is an extremist, living a life of flames and explosions. It is a myth that some of us perhaps carelessly perpetuate by showing the fiery side of our subject, giving the impression that chemists dress only in padded lab coats and helmets. More corrosively, flashy exhibitions of chemistry hide the intellectual side of our craft. Yet exploring the extremes of chemical phase space has always been fruitful and there are plenty of chemists one might choose to illustrate this.

Henri Moissan was born into a modest family, originally from the south west of France. When Moissan was 12, the family moved to Meaux, near Paris, where Moissan recalls that a brilliant chemistry teacher gave him ‘a taste for work’. Moissan’s enthusiasm for chemistry was such that he seems to have studied little else, and he left school without a full qualification. He became an apprentice to a pharmacist, but it was not the life for him. He returned to studying chemistry, accepting unpaid positions and supporting himself by tutoring.

Moissan was drawn to inorganic chemistry, a field then ignored in France, and his successes led to a poorly paid junior position in the School of Pharmacy in Paris. He took over a custom analysis lab for additional income and used the space to conduct his own experiments. The experiments were successful (determining the formula of blue perchromic acid and crystallising chromic acid itself), but the business, unsurprisingly, failed.

However, by now he was married to the daughter of the wealthy pharmacist for whom he had first worked. Financially secure, he focused his attention on one of chemistry’s unsolved problems: isolating fluorine. Both Humphrey Davy and André-Marie Ampere had proposed the existence of an elusive element responsible for fluoride salts and for an acid analogous to muriatic (hydrochloric). Davy’s electrolyses of the molten salts had all foundered through corrosion of his platinum vessels and he concluded that whatever it was must be of awesome reactivity. The challenge attracted fearless chemists like moths to a flame and several died in the attempt.

Moissan also tried electrolysis, but his experiments likewise ruined his platinum equipment with expensive predictability. The secret, he reasoned, must be to work at the lowest temperatures. He condensed hydrogen fluoride at –50°C in a platinum tube and electrolysed that. The stopper at the anode quickly charred so Moissan replaced it with calcium fluoride and now obtained a steady stream of a gas that ignited silicon and boron powder in spectacular fashion. As was the custom, the Academy of Sciences sent a team to verify the experiment. It was a total failure – Moissan had gone to such lengths to purify his HF for the trial that it was a perfect insulator. However, adding potassium bifluoride provided the electrolyte necessary and the gas streamed out.

He was promoted to the only position available: the chair of toxicology at the School of Pharmacy in Paris. If he wrote a few papers on alkaloids, his heart remained inorganic. He rapidly made a variety of main group fluorides and his work on carbon fluorides led him to imagine that they might lead to the biggest chemical prize of all – a direct preparation of diamond.

Studies of diamonds had suggested they were formed from carbon at high temperature and pressure. To achieve the high temperatures, Moissan built an arc furnace. Its body consisted of two hollowed-out blocks of lime, furnished with horizontal openings to admit a pair of carbon electrodes placed 2–3cm apart. His crucibles were made of graphitised carbon insulated with magnesia – the only oxide that could cope with the extreme conditions. Starting his steam dynamo, he would push the electrodes together until the arc struck; the furnace would ‘snore’ and then gradually go quiet, glowing first with purple cyanogen light, and then the blinding ‘lumiere Drummont’ (lime light). Flames would shoot out accompanied by ‘torrents of white smoke’. Wanting ever higher temperatures, Moissan eventually set himself up in a Paris power station where he could plough 450A at 70V through the electrodes. It was said that temperatures of 3500°C could be reached.

To achieve the high pressure, the charcoal was placed in the furnace mixed with iron – by dropping the incandescent, molten mass into water, the contraction of the iron would compress the carbon. After dissolving the nuggets, he found microscopic crystals of great hardness and density, which he would go to his death convinced were diamonds. His experiments captured the popular imagination and his peerlessly articulate undergraduate lectures were hugely oversubscribed.

In fact, Moissan had not made diamond, but instead silicon carbide, the carborundum that makes our lives go smoother. He also uncovered a huge range of borides, carbides and silicides that would unlock the bizarre worlds of main group hydrides at one end and ultrahard materials on the other. Today, arc furnaces underpin ceramics manufacturing.

Some say that Moissan was an extremist. But to me he was above all an enthusiast. As he wrote in 1897: ‘To tread a newly opened furrow, to feel complete freedom of action, and to see on all sides new vistas opening for research, brings with it a joy that only those who have had the raw pleasure of original research are fully in a position to grasp.’ He was everyone’s kind of extremist.

[Andrea Sella...teaches chemistry at University College London, UK.]

Nobelproze.org...

Henri Moissan was born in Paris on September 28, 1852. His advanced education began in the Collège de Meaux and later in Edmond Frémy's laboratory at the Musée d'Histoire Naturelle, where he attended lectures by E.H. Sainte-Claire Deville and Henri Debray. A year later, he removed to Dehérain's laboratory in the École Pratique des Haute Études and subsequently he directed a small laboratory of his own before joining Debray and Troost in the laboratories of the Sorbonne. He was appointed to a junior position in the Agronomic Institute in 1879 and he gained his doctoral degree in 1880 with a thesis on the cyanogen series. He became assistant lecturer and senior demonstrator at the School of Pharmacy and in 1886 he was elected Professor of Toxicology. In 1899 he took the Chair of Inorganic Chemistry and in 1900 he was appointed Assessor to the Director of that School. In the same year, he succeeded Troost as Professor of Inorganic Chemistry, University of Paris.

Moissan's first researches concerned the interchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the leaves of plants. He was soon to leave biology for the field of inorganic chemistry, where his early work was on the oxides of iron-group metals and chromium and a study of the chromous salts. In 1884 he turned his attention to fluorine chemistry, preparing some organic and phosphorus derivatives of that element. The following year he discovered that solutions of potassium fluoride in hydrogen fluoride at certain strengths remained liquid and conducted electrolytically at sub-zero temperatures: a year later he successfully electrolysed these solutions to isolate fluorine for the first time. He made a full study of the properties of the gas and its reactions with other elements.

In 1892, Moissan theorized that diamonds could be synthesized by crystallizing carbon under pressure from molten iron. He designed and developed the electric-arc furnace, attaining temperatures up to 3,500°C, to assist him in work which led to the production of tiny artificial stones. He subsequently used the furnace to volatilize many substances which had been regarded as infusible and to prepare many new compounds, particularly carbides, silicides and borides; in 1891 he discovered carborundum. His close study of the carbides and their reaction with water led to his theory that, in some cases, petroleum may be formed by subterraneous reaction between certain carbides and water. He prepared the hydrides of calcium, sodium and potassium and showed them to be non-conductive and, using the electric furnace, isolated many metals.

Moissan is credited with over three hundred publications, his greatest works being Le Four Électrique (The electric-arc furnace) (1897), Le Fluor et ses Composés (Fluorine and its compounds) (1900) and Traité de Chimie Minerale (Treatise on inorganic chemistry) (five volumes 1904-1906). He was an excellent lecturer and a meticulous and patient experimentalist.

Moissan, a Commandeur de la Légion d'Honneur, was elected member of the Académie de Médecine (1888), Académie des Sciences (1891), Conseil d'Hygiène de la Seine (1895 ), and the Comité Consultatif des Arts et Manufactures (1898). In 1887 he was awarded the Prix Lacaze; he was Davy medallist in 1896 and Hofmann medallist in 1903. He was honoured by the Franklin Institute of Philadelphia and awarded Fellowships of the Royal Society of London and The Chemical Society (London). He held honorary memberships of many other learned societies.

He died suddenly in Paris on February 20, 1907, shortly after his return from the prize-giving ceremony in Stockholm.

Henri Moissan [Wikipedia]